Best Wine Decanter Reviews - Wine Turtle
This post was updated on: February 1, 2020

Best Wine Decanter Reviews

Best Wine Decanter Reviews

A wine decanter is an essential accessory to have in your wine bar area. Whether you are a novice wine enthusiast or a true connoisseur, a wine decanter will add class to your wine serving and will definitely impress your guests, not to mention that it will make your wine taste better.

But with so many models available out there, determining which is the best wine decanter can be difficult. Maybe you’re also confused about wine decanting.

In this article, we are going to talk about this elegant accessory that is the decanter and tell you why and when you should decant wine. Then, our best wine decanter reviews will help you choose the right model.

What Is A Wine Decanter?

A wine decanter is a large amphora made of glass or transparent crystal. Typically all decanters have a flattened bottom and a long neck. Since there is a myriad of models available on the market, knowing how a proper wine decanter must be shaped is essential.

There are available some models of decanters that are very similar to the traditional water carafes. Many of these models are even decorated with various motifs and might seem more appealing than a traditional decanter.

While you could invest in those models, keep in mind that they might be only decorative and not always functional.

A professional decanter, however, is an indispensable item to have, especially if you take wine drinking seriously. There are many manufacturers that have their lines of professional decanters, made of either glass or crystal. The price of the item depends a lot on what material you choose.

As you can imagine, the glass decanters have more affordable prices. They can have almost the same quality as the crystal decanters. Probably the only difference between the two types is the better odor management of the crystal decanters, in the way that the crystal doesn’t preserve any aromas from the previously decanted wines.

However, if you don’t sell exclusive wines for a living, a glass wine decanter could be an excellent choice.

The most important thing that you should understand is that wine decanting is not a sommelier’s ritual or a way to impress. Wine decanting has a purpose, that of enhancing the flavor of an aged or young wine. So, if you don’t want to use your decanter only to look fashionable, you should learn the right decanting techniques.

Types Of Wine Decanters

Like we said before, wine decanters typically have flattened bottoms and long necks. This doesn’t mean that they must have the same shape.

Actually, the various types of wine decanters are different in regard to shape and capacity.

The vast majority of the wine decanters are made with a capacity of 750 ml, which is the capacity of a regular wine bottle. However, if you have to share your wine with a larger number of guests, you can choose a larger wine decanter.

The carafes can also be used for decanting purposes. However, keep in mind that the purpose of decanting is the aeration of wine and the carafe will limit this process.

Why Should You Decant The Wine?

If you are a novice, you are probably wondering by now why should you decant the wine. Well, decanting has two main objectives, that can be independent or linked between them.

One of the objectives is the aeration of the wine, while the other is the elimination of the sediment. Depending on the wine, you may have to decant it for aeration, to eliminate the sediment, or both. We mention these objectives because there is a considerable difference between the times of the two types of decantation.

The time is also a factor determined by the type of wine that needs to be decanted, especially if you want to drink a highly valuable wine.

In fact, some types of wines need only a few minutes for a proper aeration before the decanting is effective, while others, especially some exclusive varieties, may even need a few days.

Another thing to establish is the variety of wines that need decantation.

The vast majority of wines that need to be decanted are red wines, especially those made of noble varieties of grapes. However, there are some rare cases when even the white wines need decantation. These white wines are typically a few aged varieties of Jaune de Jura, Madeira or Porto.

One thing to keep in mind is that in some cases decanting the wine will alter the aroma and flavor of the wine. Therefore, if you are planning to use decanting only for scenography, you should think again.

Now let’s have a closer look at the two types of decanting.

Decanting For Aeration

This practice must be used for the aged varieties of wines. Young wines generally don’t need to be decanted.

In fact, young wines have two olfactory phases. In the first phase, you will usually perceive the strongest aromas, the primary perfumes that are generally fruity. After about 10 to 15 minutes, the strongest aromas will start to fade away giving room to the delicate secondary aromas.

Generally, these are the flowery or herbal aromas.The aged wines, in addition to these two olfactory phases, have a third aromatic bouquet that expresses the evolution of the first two phases. The roasting aromas specific to the aged wines need a proper aeration if you want to feel them. Depending on the wine, the decanting time can be from a few minutes to several hours or days.

If you are unsure about the decanting time, the best solution is to leave the wine in the decanter for a few hours before serving.

Decanting For Removing The Sediment

The other reason for decantation is to remove the wine sediment.

To remove the sediment, you should position yourself in an environment with dim light and, observing the neck of the bottle, you should slowly pour the wine into the decanter. You should pay a lot of attention to not let the sediment pass into the decanter, for this reason, it is essential to handle the bottle gently, from when you take it off the rack until you decant the wine.

If you now know the reasons of wine decanting, you should also know when decanting the wine could damage the aromas and the flavor instead of enhancing them.

First of all, it should be said that there is a lot of controversies about which wines should or shouldn’t be decanted. 

As we said above, the aged wines should be decanted. However, this is not a universal rule. In fact, in some cases, the old wines can be damaged by prolonged exposure to oxygen. For this reason, unless specified by the winemaker or by a wine expert, you should never keep the wine in the decanter more than a few hours.

Generally, young or white wines don’t need decanting. While there is no precise rule, the main thing to keep in mind is that you shouldn’t leave white wine or young wine in a decanter for more than half an hour.

Now, read our best wine decanter reviews and decide which one you want to add to your collection.

Best Wine Decanter Reviews

1. Vinomaster Crystal Red Wine Decanter Carafe

Vinomaster Crystal Red Wine Decanter Carafe

If you want to impress your guests or customers, this Crystal Red Wine Decanter Carafe from Vinomaster is probably the best investment you could make.

This attractive wine decanter has a beautiful, elegant design and it is perfectly engineered to bring out all the aromas and flavor of your wine.

The decanter has a capacity of 750 ml and the slanted spout will allow you to pour the wine from the decanter into the glass easily and without spills.

The optimal surface will ensure a proper aeration of your vintage red wines, although you can decant the wines as well since the crystal don’t absorb any odors from the previously decanted wines.

Things We Liked

  • Hand-blown: this marvelous decanter is made of lead-free crystal and it is 100% hand-blown, being an excellent choice for any wine lover.
  • Elegant design: matching all wine bars, this decanter boasts an elegant design.
  • The perfect gift: this decanter is the perfect gift for all wine lovers, for novices and connoisseurs alike.
  • Optimal breathable surface: your aged wines will benefit from a proper aeration thanks to the wide breathable area.

Things We Didn't Like

  • Some customers complained about the quality of the packaging, claiming that it doesn’t protect well the decanter during shipping.

2. Menu Winebreather Carafe

Menu Winebreather Carafe

The Menu Winebreather Carafe is an innovative wine decanter that impresses not only with its design but with the original way of pouring the wine into it.

Basically, the decanter should be placed on top of an opened bottle of wine. Press the decanter to fit the neck of the bottle well and switch places. All the wine will pour into the decanter, receiving enough oxygen because of the way it flows.

When it comes to serving, you can choose to flip the bottle-decanter in the original position and serve the wine from the bottle or serve it directly from the decanter.

Things We Liked

  • Elegant design: this wine decanter boasts an elegant and minimalist design that can complement all wine bars.
  • Innovative decanting solution: this is one of the most original wine decanters available on the market.
  • Stainless steel elements: the pouring cap is made of stainless steel and it can be easily cleaned.
  • Large capacity: this wine decanter can properly aerate up to 1000ml of wine.

Things We Didn't Like

  • Some users complained about the poor customer service.

3. Sagaform Wine Carafe With Oak Stopper

Sagaform Wine Carafe With Oak Stopper

Another elegant wine decanter we really like is this Wine Carafe With Oak Stopper from Sagaform.

This wine decanter is made of hand-blown glass. It has a traditional shape and a beautiful oak stopper that will keep the wine away from dust.

You can fit even a magnum bottle of wine into this decanter, thanks to the large capacity. When it comes to the cleaning ease, the decanter can be easily cleaned with warm water or you can wash it in the dishwasher.

Things We Liked

  • Elegant shape: this wine decanter has a beautiful oval shape and the round oak stopper adds a lot of class to the carafe.
  • Hand-blown: this decanter is made of hand-blown glass.
  • Great gift idea: this wine decanter can make a beautiful gift for any wine enthusiast.
  • Easy to clean: thanks to the shape, the decanter is really easy to clean with warm water. It can also be washed in the dishwasher.

Things We Didn't Like

  • Some customers complained about the quality of the glass, claiming that it is too thin and delicate.

4. Luigi Bormioli Magnifico 35-ounce Decanter

Luigi Bormioli Magnifico 35-ounce Decanter

A splendid wine decanter that impressed us is this Luigi Bormioli Magnifico, a decanter with an original shape that is a confirmation of the Italian style.

Looking more like a water carafe, this decanter boasts a practical punt that will ensure a proper aeration for all the liquid.

The decanter has a one-liter capacity, although it is advisable to decant only 750 ml at a time, to make sure that all the wine will come in contact with the oxygen.

Things We Liked

  • Beautiful shape: with an unusual shape for a wine decanter, this unit will surely impress your guests and family.
  • Easy to use: pouring the wine from the decanter into the glass is really easy, thanks to the optimal shape of the lip.
  • Easy to clean: thanks to the wide opening and large surface, the decanter is really easy to clean.
  • Made in Italy: this wine decanter is manufactured in Italy in a famous glass factory.

Things We Didn't Like

  • The decanter is made of machine-blown glass and it is not perfectly finished.

5. Kitchen Gizmo Wine Decanter, Aerator and Wine Glass

Kitchen Gizmo Wine Decanter, Aerator and Wine Glass

Another innovative wine decanter we really like comes from Kitchen Gizmo. This three-in-one combo is composed of a decanter, an aerator accessory and a wine glass that can also be used as a decanter cap.

The shape and composition of the assembly are really innovative and if you’re looking for a perfect gift or for a wine accessory to impress your guests, this might be a great choice.

The contemporary design is simply beautiful and, although modern, it can match any type of interior.

Things We Liked

  • High-quality glass: the decanter, together with the other accessories, is made of hand-blown borosilicate glass.
  • Easy to clean: this decanter is dishwasher safe, being really easy to clean.
  • Practical: with one product you will get not only a decanter but also a useful aerator and a wine glass.
  • Excellent price: for the quality of the glass and the versatility of the product, this wine decanter combo has a very fair price

Things We Didn't Like

  • The decanter, together with the glass and with the aerator are pretty heavy, so keep that in mind when serving the wine. The glass is not suitable for tasting the wine.

Conclusion and Final Pick

As our best wine decanter reviews show, there are enough options on the market to match all tastes and budgets.

However, our favorite wine decanter is the Vinomaster Crystal Red Wine Decanter Carafe.

The first thing we like about this wine decanter is that is made of crystal and not of glass. For many wines this may not be an important characteristic, but if you have a collection of very rare wines, the material of the decanter really makes a difference.

Being made of crystal, this decanter doesn’t absorb the odors of the previously decanted wines, ensuring a proper tasting of your exclusive drink.

The shape is another feature we really like. The wide oval base is perfect for a proper aeration of the liquid. In addition, the long neck and the perfectly designed lip makes pouring the wine easy.

The capacity of the decanter is also the desired one. Usually, there is no reason to decant more than 750 ml of wine at a time. If you have more guests, we suggest using two or more decanters.

The reason why we don’t advise decanting more than 750 ml of wine is because larger quantities of liquid are harder to aerate, therefore the wine might not show its true notes and character.

All these characteristics, together with the fact that it is hand-blown, make us consider the Vinomaster Crystal Red Wine Decanter Carafe the best wine decanter available on the market.

About the Author

Although not having any formal training in wine, Tim has developed an irrefutable love of wine and interest in anything related to it ever since he was a little kid. Coming from a family of wine lovers, it was from a young age that he got exposed to wine and the culture that goes with it and has been addicted ever since. Having traveled to dozens of wine regions across the world including those in France, Italy, California, Australia, and South Africa and tasted a large selection of their wines, it is with great joy that he hopes to share those experiences here and take you along on the journey.

Leave a Reply 0 comments